Regular Article“Voxel-Based Morphometry” Should Not Be Used with Imperfectly Registered Images
Abstract
John Ashburner and Karl Friston (2000) introduced a standardized method of “voxel-based morphometry” (VBM) for comparisons of local concentrations of gray matter between two groups of subjects. Segmented images of gray matter from grossly normalized high-resolution images are smoothed and their group differences analyzed by the now-conventional voxelwise Worsley approach to Gaussian random fields of differences. This comment concerns an unfortunate interaction between the algorithm's spatial normalization and voxelwise comparison steps, whereby several obvious quantitative confounds are injected at the core of the inference engine the authors put forward. Specifically, the statistics of the resulting voxelwise comparisons are uninformative about group differences wherever the spatial normalization algorithm has failed to register on any robustly appearing image gradient. The method of Ashburner and Friston is defensible only far from all image gradients.
References (13)
- J. Ashburner et al.
Incorporating prior knowledge into image registration
NeuroImage
(1997) - J. Ashburner et al.
Voxel-based morphometry—The methods
NeuroImage
(2000) - F.L. Bookstein
Linear methods for nonlinear maps: Procrustes fits, thin-plate splines, and the biometric analysis of shape variability
- N.C. Andreasen et al.
Thalamic abnormalities in schizophrenia visualized through magnetic resonance image averaging
Science
(1994) - J. Ashburner et al.
Nonlinear spatial normalization using basis functions
Hum. Brain Mapp.
(1999) - E.T. Bullmore et al.
Global, voxel, and cluster tests, by theory and permutation for a difference between two groups of structural MR images of the brain
IEEE Trans. Med. Imag.
(1999)
Cited by (585)
Optimal transport features for morphometric population analysis
2023, Medical Image AnalysisBrain pathologies often manifest as partial or complete loss of tissue. The goal of many neuroimaging studies is to capture the location and amount of tissue changes with respect to a clinical variable of interest, such as disease progression. Morphometric analysis approaches capture local differences in the distribution of tissue or other quantities of interest in relation to a clinical variable. We propose to augment morphometric analysis with an additional feature extraction step based on unbalanced optimal transport. The optimal transport feature extraction step increases statistical power for pathologies that cause spatially dispersed tissue loss, minimizes sensitivity to shifts due to spatial misalignment or differences in brain topology, and separates changes due to volume differences from changes due to tissue location. We demonstrate the proposed optimal transport feature extraction step in the context of a volumetric morphometric analysis of the OASIS-1 study for Alzheimer’s disease. The results demonstrate that the proposed approach can identify tissue changes and differences that are not otherwise measurable.
A review on Alzheimer's disease classification from normal controls and mild cognitive impairment using structural MR images
2023, Journal of Neuroscience MethodsAlzheimer’s disease (AD) is an irreversible neurodegenerative brain disorder that degrades the memory and cognitive ability in elderly people. The main reason for memory loss and reduction in cognitive ability is the structural changes in the brain that occur due to neuronal loss. These structural changes are most conspicuous in the hippocampus, cortex, and grey matter and can be assessed by using neuroimaging techniques viz. Positron Emission Tomography (PET), structural Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) and functional MRI (fMRI), etc. Out of these neuroimaging techniques, structural MRI has evolved as the best technique as it indicates the best soft tissue contrast and high spatial resolution which is important for AD detection. Currently, the focus of researchers is on predicting the conversion of Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI) into AD. MCI represents the transition state between expected cognitive changes with normal aging and Alzheimer’s disease. Not every MCI patient progresses into Alzheimer’s disease. MCI can develop into stable MCI (sMCI, patients are called non-converters) or into progressive MCI (pMCI, patients are diagnosed as MCI converters). This paper discusses the prognosis of MCI to AD conversion and presents a review of structural MRI-based studies for AD detection. AD detection framework includes feature extraction, feature selection, and classification process. This paper reviews the studies for AD detection based on different feature extraction methods and machine learning algorithms for classification. The performance of various feature extraction methods has been compared and it has been observed that the wavelet transform-based feature extraction method would give promising results for AD classification. The present study indicates that researchers are successful in classifying AD from Normal Controls (NrmC) but, it still requires a lot of work to be done for MCI/ NrmC and MCI/AD, which would help in detecting AD at its early stage.
A gendered brain perspective from structure to brain interactions
2023, Principles of Gender-Specific Medicine: Sex and Gender-Specific Biology in the Postgenomic EraThis chapter overviews the structural and functional brain connectivity differences underlying gender identity by reviewing cisgender and transgender literature. Reports are overall inconclusive and somewhat discrepant due to heterogeneous small samples. Structurally, predominant involvement of the parietal, frontal, and occipital cortices, the putamen, and the thalamus are described as gray matter volume features of binary gender groups. Functionally, a network-based whole-brain paradigm is presented to study the network interactions and spatiotemporal dynamics supporting the construction of a gendered self. The parietal cortex and frontal lobe nodes are the most reported in discriminating transgender and cisgender groups. In addition, the salience network is proposed as a cornerstone for gender, responsible for modulating the interactions with the internal and external world. A neurodevelopmental hypothesis provides an explanation for the construction of gender identity in the brain, based on the review of structural and functional data as well as genetic findings.
Rapid volumetric brain changes after acute psychosocial stress
2023, NeuroImageStress is an important trigger for brain plasticity: Acute stress can rapidly affect brain activity and functional connectivity, and chronic or pathological stress has been associated with structural brain changes. Measures of structural magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) can be modified by short-term motor learning or visual stimulation, suggesting that they also capture rapid brain changes. Here, we investigated volumetric brain changes (together with changes in T1 relaxation rate and cerebral blood flow) after acute stress in humans as well as their relation to psychophysiological stress measures.
Sixty-seven healthy men (25.8±2.7 years) completed a standardized psychosocial laboratory stressor (Trier Social Stress Test) or a control version while blood, saliva, heart rate, and psychometrics were sampled. Structural MRI (T1 mapping / MP2RAGE sequence) at 3T was acquired 45 min before and 90 min after intervention onset. Grey matter volume (GMV) changes were analysed using voxel-based morphometry. Associations with endocrine, autonomic, and subjective stress measures were tested with linear models.
We found significant group-by-time interactions in several brain clusters including anterior/mid-cingulate cortices and bilateral insula: GMV was increased in the stress group relative to the control group, in which several clusters showed a GMV decrease. We found a significant group-by-time interaction for cerebral blood flow, and a main effect of time for T1 values (longitudinal relaxation time). In addition, GMV changes were significantly associated with state anxiety and heart rate variability changes.
Such rapid GMV changes assessed with VBM may be induced by local tissue adaptations to changes in energy demand following neural activity. Our findings suggest that endogenous brain changes are counteracted by acute psychosocial stress, which emphasizes the importance of considering homeodynamic processes and generally highlights the influence of stress on the brain.
In chronic complete spinal cord injury supraspinal changes detected by quantitative MRI are confined to volume reduction in the caudal brainstem
2021, NeuroImage: ClinicalThere is much controversy about the potential impact of spinal cord injury (SCI) on brain anatomy and function, which is mirrored in the substantial divergence of findings between animal models and human imaging studies. Given recent advances in quantitative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) we sought to tackle the unresolved question about the link between the presumed injury associated volume differences and underlying brain tissue property changes in a cohort of chronic complete SCI patients. Using the established computational anatomy methods of voxel-based morphometry (VBM) and voxel-based quantification (VBQ), we performed statistical analyses on grey and white matter volumes as well as on parameter maps indicative for myelin, iron, and free tissue water content in the brain of complete SCI patients (n = 14) and healthy individuals (n = 14). Our regionally unbiased white matter analysis showed a significant volume reduction of the dorsal aspect at the junction between the most rostral part of the spinal cord and the medulla oblongata consistent with Wallerian degeneration of proprioceptive axons in the dorsal column tracts in SCI subjects. This observation strongly correlated with spinal cord atrophy assessed by quantification of the spinal cord cross-sectional area at the cervical level C2/3. These findings suggest that Wallerian degeneration of the dorsal column tracts represents a main contributor to the observed spinal cord atrophy, which is highly consistent with preclinical histological evidence of remote changes in the central nervous system secondary to SCI. Structural changes in other brain regions representing remote changes in the course of chronic SCI could neither be confirmed by conventional VBM nor by VBQ analysis. Whether and how MRI based brain morphometry and brain tissue property analysis will inform clinical decision making and clinical trial outcomes in spinal cord medicine remains to be determined.
Sensorimotor white matter projections and disease severity in primary Restless Legs Syndrome/Willis-Ekbom disease: a multimodal DTI analysis
2020, Sleep MedicineRestless Legs Syndrome, a potentially disabling sleep disorder, also known as Willis-Ekbom disease (RLS/WED), may be caused by loss of inhibitory modulation of descending central motor pathways, structural changes in the somatosensory cortex, abnormal connectivity between motor and sensory areas, as well as by subtle abnormalities in white matter micro-organization.
To compare diffusion-tensor imaging (DTI) metrics in areas associated with sensory or motor function, as well as sensorimotor integration, between subjects with primary mild-to-severe RLS/WED and controls.
DTI metrics were assessed in 38 subjects with RLS/WED (14 mild to moderate, 24 severe to very severe) and 24 healthy age-matched controls with whole-brain Tract Based Spatial Statistics (TBSS), Region-of-interest (ROI) and probabilistic tractography based analyses. The ROIs corresponded to the corticospinal tract (CST) at the level of the cerebral peduncle; the superior, middle and inferior cerebellar peduncles. Subgroup analyses were made according to the severity of RLS/WED symptoms. The corticospinal tract was evaluated with probabilistic tractography. We also explored associations between significant findings and severity of symptoms with the Spearman's correlation coefficient.
TBSS analysis revealed decreased axial diffusivity (AD) in the left posterior thalamic radiation in RLS/WED. In subjects with severe RLS/WED, AD was reduced in the left posterior corona radiata and this reduction was negatively correlated with severity of symptoms. ROI-based analysis showed that radial diffusivity (RD) was increased in the superior cerebellar peduncles of individuals with severe RLS/WED. Tractography did not show between-group or subgroup differences.
Our results are consistent with subtle white matter changes, prominently in RLS/WED subjects with more severe symptoms, in areas related to sensory or motor function, as well as to sensorimotor integration, compared to controls. These findings support the hypothesis, raised by prior pathophysiological studies, of defective integration within these networks.